The twenty-two women at the center of the operation were murder victims. They had not consented to public disclosure of their physical features, their clothing, their distinctive marks. They were deceased, and their estates — to the extent that such legal concepts applied — could not give or withhold consent on their behalf. The decision to release photographs and detailed descriptions was made by investigators on behalf of a process they believed served the interests of justice and of the victims themselves: the restoration of their names.

 

This is a reasonable position. The interest of a murder victim in having their name restored — in having the institutional record corrected to reflect who they actually were — is a compelling interest, and it is one that the victim cannot advocate for themselves. The investigators who release this information are acting as advocates for people who can no longer advocate for themselves.

 

But the ethics of such releases also require attention to the specifics. The release of a tattoo photograph is different from the release of a crime scene photograph. The release of physical description information is different from the release of graphic details of the manner of death. Operation Identify Me was designed with these distinctions in mind: the goal was to release the information most useful for identification — the tattoo, the clothing, the physical description — while avoiding the kind of graphic disclosure that would add to the indignity of an already undignified circumstance.

 

The temporary names given to the victims also reflect an ethical consideration: the names are descriptive, not demeaning. They point to distinctive features rather than to the circumstances of death. “The woman with the flower tattoo” describes Rita Roberts by something she chose to put on her body, not by where she was found or how she died.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.