As investigators dug into Harvey’s background, they found a pattern that was troubling in retrospect.
His second wife, Joan, had died in 1949. The circumstances were unusual. Harvey had been driving near Eglin Air Force Base in Florida when his car went off a bridge. Joan, his wife, drowned. Her mother, who was also in the car, drowned as well. Harvey survived. He collected Joan’s life insurance.
He had been in several boat-related incidents that produced insurance payouts. His friends and acquaintances, interviewed after the *Bluebelle* case, described a man who had a history of financial trouble and a history of surviving disasters that killed the people around him.
His military record also contained anomalies. Harvey had flown combat missions in both World War II and Korea, and his record included a number of incidents in which aircraft under his command had experienced “engine failure” that required emergency landings or bailouts. Some of these incidents were documented; others were described by former colleagues who had grown suspicious of their frequency.
The double indemnity insurance policy on Mary Dene’s life — the $20,000 policy that Harvey had taken out two months before the voyage — was a significant piece of the picture. A double indemnity policy pays out at twice the face value if the insured person dies by accident rather than natural causes. A drowning at sea, in a sudden squall, would qualify. The policy was taken out in September 1961. The *Bluebelle* voyage was November. The timing was not subtle.
