The Coast Guard’s investigation concluded, in a report dated April 25, 1962, that Harvey had killed Arthur Duperrault, Jean Duperrault, Brian Duperrault, and Mary Dene Harvey, and had attempted to kill Terry Jo. The report found that the most probable cause of the disaster was Harvey’s mental state — specifically, his decision to murder his wife in order to collect the insurance payout, and the subsequent decision to kill the witnesses to that murder. The report concluded that Harvey had deliberately scuttled the *Bluebelle* to cover the evidence.
The report also addressed René Duperrault’s death. The seven-year-old girl had been found alive in Harvey’s dinghy, and Harvey had presented her to the crew of the *Gulf Lion* as already dead. The investigators concluded that René most likely survived the sinking but drowned at some point; they could not determine whether Harvey had allowed her to drown deliberately or whether she had died before he was rescued. The specific manner of her death remained unclear.
If Harvey had lived, the report stated, he would have been prosecuted for the murders and the attempted murder of Terry Jo Duperrault.
He had not lived. His death by suicide meant that no criminal trial ever took place, no formal charge was ever filed, and no verdict was ever rendered by a court. The Coast Guard’s conclusion — that Harvey committed the murders — was an administrative finding, not a legal verdict. It was, however, a finding reached by experienced investigators who had access to both testimonies, the physical evidence, and the full context of Harvey’s history.
