Arthur and Jean had three children who, by the evidence of the accounts that survive them, were recognizable as individuals rather than simply as the victims of a catastrophe. Brian at 14 was the teenager; he owned the rifle that Harvey was later said to have been carrying when he appeared in Terry Jo’s cabin doorway, which suggests a family that had given their adolescent son some of the responsibilities and equipment of outdoor life in the Upper Midwest. Terry Jo at 11 was the middle child — old enough to have her own cabin on the boat, old enough to wake and respond to screaming and go toward it rather than freeze. René at 7 was the youngest, the one whose death remains most unclear in its specific circumstances.

 

The family vacation that brought them to the *Bluebelle* was funded by years of saving. The charter fee was $515, which was a significant sum for a week’s activity in 1961, and the broader cost of the trip — the flights to Fort Lauderdale, the hotels, the incidentals of a week in the Bahamas — would have been substantially more. This was not a casual purchase. It was the culmination of planning that Arthur had been doing since his wartime experiences in the Caribbean, executed at the moment when the family finances and the children’s ages aligned to make it possible.

 

That Arthur told the British district commissioner Roderick Pinder, on November 12, that it had been a “once-in-a-lifetime vacation” is both a record of his happiness and, in retrospect, one of the more quietly devastating details of the case. He said it on the last day of his life, to a stranger, as a simple and accurate expression of how the week had felt. He had no reason to think it would be his last day, or that the phrase would be remembered because it was the last report of his happiness before whatever happened that night.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.