—

## The Broader Question of Neanderthal Social Life

The Chagyrskaya study contributes a data point to a question about Neanderthal social life that has been debated for decades and that still lacks a definitive answer: how complex was Neanderthal social organization?

The traditional view, dominant through much of the twentieth century, was that Neanderthals were cognitively and behaviorally simpler than anatomically modern humans — less linguistically sophisticated, less capable of symbolic thought, organized in smaller and simpler social groups. This view was supported partly by archaeological evidence: Neanderthal sites generally lack the elaborate symbolic artifacts — ornaments, figurines, complex pigment use — that appear in early modern human sites. It was also supported by inferences from neuroanatomy: Neanderthal skull morphology differs from modern humans’ in ways that some researchers have argued reflect differences in brain organization relevant to language and cognition.

The revisionist view, which has gained ground in recent decades, is that Neanderthals were cognitively and socially more complex than the traditional account acknowledged — that the apparent simplicity of their material culture reflects differences in ecology or population density rather than cognitive inferiority, and that their behavior included forms of symbolic thought, care for the disabled, and long-distance exchange that indicate social complexity comparable in important respects to that of early modern humans.

The Chagyrskaya findings are relevant to this debate in a limited but specific way. The genetic evidence for female migration between communities implies that Neanderthal social organization was not simply a matter of isolated family groups with no connections beyond their immediate vicinity. The movement of females between communities implies that there were multiple communities within a region, that those communities were aware of each other, and that some mechanism — however different from modern human marriage practices it may have been — enabled the movement of individuals between them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.