Before any kinship analysis could be performed, the researchers had to establish which specimens actually came from the same individual. When a site yields dozens of small bone and tooth fragments, the same person can contribute multiple specimens — teeth shed at different ages, bone fragments from different anatomical elements — that would not automatically be recognized as coming from the same person without genetic analysis.

The team identified several cases where multiple specimens proved to be from the same individual.

One example: three teeth — one deciduous (a baby tooth) and two permanent teeth — came from a single male individual. Shared mitochondrial DNA variants across the three specimens confirmed they were from the same person. This individual became Chagyrskaya G, identified as male and aged roughly 9 to 15 at death based on the dental development indicated by the mix of deciduous and permanent teeth.

Another case: a mandible (lower jaw, specimen Chagyrskaya 6) and an incisor (Chagyrskaya 14) proved to be from the same individual, designated Chagyrskaya C.

A third: two previously analyzed specimens, Chagyrskaya 12 and Chagyrskaya 8 (the latter had been published in an earlier study), turned out to be from one individual — Chagyrskaya F.

One individual, designated Chagyrskaya E, showed such genetic similarity to Chagyrskaya D that the two may have been the same person. The team removed Chagyrskaya E from certain analyses to avoid double-counting.

This process of de-replication — confirming which specimens belonged to which individuals — was a prerequisite for the kinship analysis that followed. Working from the wrong assumptions about individual counts would have distorted every subsequent inference.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.