—
## The Kinship Method: What Shared DNA Actually Measures
The core method the researchers used to establish kinship relationships is based on a straightforward principle of Mendelian genetics: close relatives share more of their DNA than distant relatives, and the degree of sharing follows predictable rules.
Parents and children share approximately 50 percent of their nuclear genome — each parent contributes half. Full siblings also share approximately 50 percent on average, though the specific segments shared vary. Grandparents and grandchildren, aunts and nieces, and half-siblings share approximately 25 percent. The statistical measure the team used — normalized pairwise nuclear divergence, expressed as p0 — translates these sharing levels into numerical values: roughly 0.75 for first-degree relatives, roughly 0.875 for second-degree relatives, and 1.0 for unrelated individuals. (Lower values mean more sharing; identical individuals would score 0.5.)
The analysis of Chagyrskaya D and Chagyrskaya H returned a p0 value of approximately 0.77, consistent with a first-degree relationship. But which first-degree relationship?
The candidates were: parent-child (either father-daughter or mother-daughter or father-son or mother-son) and full siblings. Discriminating between these required additional evidence.
The first line of evidence was sex. Chagyrskaya D was determined from the X-chromosome coverage to be male. Chagyrskaya H was determined to be female. This rules out brother-brother or sister-sister pairings at the outset. Among the remaining possibilities — father-daughter, mother-son, brother-sister, or father-son or mother-daughter where one sex determination was unreliable — the sex assignments pointed toward parent-child relationships.
The second line of evidence was mitochondrial DNA. Mitochondrial DNA is inherited exclusively from the mother. If the relationship were mother and child — in either direction — the two individuals would share the same mitochondrial lineage (barring rare mutation). If the relationship were full siblings who shared the same mother, they would also share the same mitochondrial lineage.
