But the typewriter had a prior history that did not depend on its physical recovery. Leopold had used the portable Underwood at meetings of his law school study group at the University of Chicago, where members typed notes and circulated them among themselves. Those documents still existed. And when the font and the specific characteristics of the typeface in those documents were compared to the font and characteristics of the ransom note, the match was clear.

The ransom note had been typed on Nathan Leopold’s Underwood.

—

## The Alibi Collapses

Leopold and Loeb had prepared an alibi. They had been together on the afternoon of May 21, they said, driving around in Leopold’s car, spending time with two young women they had met. The women were named Edna and Mae — they provided no last names, and offered vague descriptions that could apply to virtually any young women in Chicago.

This story had a fundamental problem: it was false, and there were witnesses who could disprove it.

One of those witnesses was Sven Englund, the Leopold family’s chauffeur. Englund had a specific, documented recollection of May 21, 1924. The Leopold car, he said, had not left the garage during the time Leopold claimed he had been using it — specifically between approximately one and ten in the evening. His wife supported his account, and there was additional corroboration: a prescription slip from a local drugstore, dated May 21, that placed Englund or his wife in a location inconsistent with the alibi story.

The alibi that had seemed carefully constructed — two young men, a drive, some girls whose names they couldn’t quite remember — was hollow. The chauffeur had no reason to lie. The prescription slip was contemporaneous documentation.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.