And then he announced that he would not impose the death penalty.

His stated reasons were specific. He cited the age of the defendants — their youth, the fact that they were not yet fully formed adults at the time of the crime. He acknowledged that Illinois law permitted a judge, in a guilty plea, to consider age as a mitigating factor, and he stated that he was doing so. He noted that future authorities studying criminal psychology might find value in examining defendants who had committed a crime of this nature, an oddly forward-looking observation that acknowledged the psychiatric dimension of the case without fully endorsing it.

He sentenced each defendant to life imprisonment for the murder of Bobby Franks, plus an additional ninety-nine years for the kidnapping charge. The sentences would run consecutively, not concurrently.

There would be no execution.

The reaction in Chicago was divided and fierce. Many people — including many in the press — were outraged. The sense that wealth had purchased a special outcome, that two young men from prominent families had escaped the rope through the services of an expensive attorney and a compliant judge, was widespread and persistent. Robert Crowe called the decision a miscarriage of justice. Letters poured into newspapers. The case entered the vocabulary of a certain kind of civic resentment about inequality before the law — a resentment that was not without basis.

Others saw the decision as a moment of genuine progress — an acknowledgment that the courts could and should consider the developmental circumstances that produced criminal behavior, that youth was a legally and morally relevant factor, and that capital punishment served no purpose that life imprisonment could not equally serve.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.