This reading of Nietzsche is a distortion of what Nietzsche actually wrote, and commentators at the time and since have noted as much. Nietzsche’s actual conception of the Übermensch was far more demanding, far less self-serving, and far more concerned with the creation of genuine values than with the license to ignore the values of others. The version that Leopold absorbed was essentially an adolescent misreading — a convenient rationalization that happened to arrive dressed in the language of serious philosophy.

But the misreading was consequential. It had given Leopold a framework for the crime that made it, to him, something other than a crime. It was an exercise. A demonstration. A proof of his own category of being. That framework had not caused the crime, but it had provided a structure within which the crime could be contemplated and carried out.

The case prompted a wider public discussion about what was being taught at universities, about whether philosophy could be dangerous, about whether the great books of Western thought contained hazards for certain kinds of readers. These discussions were largely overwrought — the universities were not responsible for Nathan Leopold’s narcissism — but they reflected a genuine anxiety about how ideas could be weaponized by those who chose to adopt them selectively.

Darrow addressed this dimension of the case in his summation, arguing that Leopold had been taught the Superman idea “in the university” and that it was not entirely fair to hold him responsible for having taken it seriously. This was a deliberately provocative argument, and Crowe responded to it with appropriate force. But it was also an argument that gestured toward something real: that the environments in which people develop — including their educational environments, their family environments, the books they read and the ideas they absorb — shape who they become in ways that simple moral accounting does not fully capture.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.