—

## The Persistent Questions

The Leopold and Loeb case has never entirely left the American cultural and legal imagination. It has been the subject of novels, films, plays, and academic studies in every decade since 1924. It raises questions that have not aged.

The first is the question of motive. We understand, in outline, what Leopold and Loeb said motivated them: the desire to commit a perfect crime, the Nietzschean framework, the dynamics of their relationship. But understanding the stated motive does not resolve the deeper question of why two young men who had been given every advantage — wealth, education, intelligence, opportunity — chose to destroy a boy they barely knew. The case sits permanently in the gap between explanation and comprehension.

The second is the question of privilege. The Franks family lost a son. Jacob Franks was a wealthy man, but no wealth could restore Bobby, could repair what had been done to him, could make the ransom note and the telephone call and the culvert near Wolf Lake into something other than what they were. The defendants, by contrast, had access to Clarence Darrow, to a legal strategy of unusual sophistication, to a hearing before a thoughtful judge rather than a hostile jury. Whether the outcome — life imprisonment rather than death — would have been the same for defendants without those resources is a question the case does not answer. It insists on being asked.

The third is the question of punishment. What is the death penalty for? Darrow’s argument was that it served no purpose that honest analysis could identify. Crowe’s argument was that some crimes demanded the ultimate response, that the law without that ultimate response became something less than law. Neither argument has ever been finally resolved in American jurisprudence. The death penalty remains in use in some American states, abolished in others, contested everywhere. The Leopold and Loeb case is part of the evidence that people cite in that ongoing argument.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.