And yet the case persists.
It persists in part because it remains unusually clear about the specific form of evil it documents. This was not a crime of poverty or desperation. It was not the product of addiction or mental illness in any simple sense. It was the product of two young men who had been given everything and found that everything was not enough — who decided that the ultimate expression of their specialness would be a crime that demonstrated their superiority over ordinary moral constraints.
The fantasy of the perfect crime — the idea that intelligence and planning could place a person beyond the reach of consequence — is not unique to 1924 or to Kenwood or to Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb. It has appeared in various forms throughout the history of crime, and it appears in the imaginations of people who have never committed and would never commit any crime at all. What the Leopold and Loeb case demonstrates, with almost pedagogical clarity, is that the fantasy is false.
Intelligence was not enough. Planning was not enough. The elaborate arrangements — the alibi, the ransom, the typewriter, the disposal of the body — were not enough. Because a railroad worker named Tony Minke walked along the tracks near Wolf Lake on the morning of May 22 and found something that should not have been there, and because a detective examined a pair of glasses and noticed an unusual hinge, and because a Brooklyn manufacturer had patented that hinge and sold it to one Chicago retailer who had sold it to three customers one of whom was Nathan Leopold.
