The elements were all there: a victim with a fully humanized life, perpetrators whose psychology invited analysis, a legal proceeding that raised genuine questions about the limits and purposes of the law, a cast of secondary characters — the families, the attorneys, the judge, the reporters — whose perspectives added dimension to the central story. The case was complicated enough that it resisted simple moral categories, while remaining specific enough that the complexity was grounded in documented facts rather than abstraction.

Maurine Watkins, covering the case for the Tribune, was absorbing lessons about how narrative and crime and spectacle interacted that she would spend the rest of her career working through. Meyer Levin, whose novel *Compulsion* would come a quarter-century later, was a teenager in Chicago in 1924, attending some of the same schools as the principal figures, absorbing the case at a formative age in a way that would eventually shape his most important work.

The case also demonstrated, in ways that became models for subsequent coverage, how a true crime narrative could serve multiple purposes simultaneously: documenting what had happened, analyzing why it had happened, examining the social and institutional contexts in which it had happened, and raising questions about justice and punishment that the specific case could not fully answer but could clarify. The best true crime writing of the subsequent century has worked within this template, often without its practitioners being fully aware that they are following a pattern that the Leopold and Loeb case helped establish.

—

## Nathan Leopold as Teacher and Scientist

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.