—

## The Specific Weight of the Evidence

Looking at the Leopold and Loeb case from the vantage point of a century later, the most striking aspect of the investigation is how specifically and independently each piece of evidence pointed toward the same conclusion.

The glasses pointed to Leopold through the Bobrow hinge at Almer Coe, three sales records, one woman eliminated, one man confirmed in Europe, one Nathan Leopold at 4754 Greenwood Avenue.

The typewriter pointed to Leopold through the ransom note’s characteristics, the study group notes that established the machine’s distinctive typeface, and eventually the physical recovery of the machine from the lagoon after Leopold and Loeb had disposed of it.

The alibi pointed to both Leopold and Loeb through Sven Englund’s specific, corroborated, documented recollection that the Leopold car had not been used during the hours in question.

The confessions, once produced, confirmed and elaborated what the physical evidence had already strongly suggested.

Each of these lines of evidence was independent. If the glasses had not been found — or if they had been generic frames that could not be traced — the investigation might still have produced the typewriter evidence and the alibi collapse. If the typewriter had been cleaned before disposal — if Leopold had been more careful — the glasses and the alibi might still have been enough. The evidence was redundant in a way that the two killers had not anticipated, because they had not thought about the investigation’s toolkit with sufficient specificity.

They had thought about their own plan. They had not thought about the detective’s plan — the systematic, patient, documentary approach to following physical and testimonial evidence from artifact to source to identity. That is the approach that worked.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.