This was an overdetermined response. The universities had not caused what Leopold and Loeb did. Nietzsche had not caused what Leopold and Loeb did. The misreading of philosophical texts by troubled young men is as old as philosophy, and placing the blame on the texts or the institutions that assigned them is a category error that substitutes a convenient culprit for the more uncomfortable analysis of what had actually produced these particular killers.

But the anxiety was not entirely misplaced. Something specific had happened — something specific about the combination of wealth, isolation, intellectual arrogance, and the specific dynamics of the Leopold-Loeb relationship — that had produced people capable of planning and executing a murder with the detachment of a game move. And the question of whether that combination was, in some sense, a product of the culture that surrounded them — of its values, its assumptions, its inadequate attention to what it was doing to the children it raised — was not an absurd question.

The 1920s ended in economic collapse. The prosperity that had seemed to confirm the culture’s assumptions about itself turned out to be fragile. And the Leopold and Loeb case, which had occurred at something close to the period’s height, remained in the cultural memory as a cautionary illustration — not of anything simple, but of the specific kind of harm that unchecked privilege combined with adolescent grandiosity could produce.

—

## Documentation and Memory

The historical record of the Leopold and Loeb case is unusually rich, partly because of the press coverage that documented the proceedings in real time and partly because several of the principal figures left their own accounts.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.