Nathan Leopold had carried in his jacket pocket the specific, traceable object that would connect him to the culvert near Wolf Lake, and he had not known he was carrying it. The plan had not accounted for the glasses because the glasses had not been part of the plan — they were simply there, the way objects are simply there when you carry them without thinking about them.

A patented hinge. A single Chicago retailer. Three sales records. One name.

The crime was not perfect. It had never been. And the specific, physical, undramatic reason it was not perfect was a pair of horn-rimmed tortoiseshell glasses with an unusual hinge, lying in the mud near a railroad culvert, waiting for someone to look.

—

## Corroboration and the Architecture of a Case

The Leopold and Loeb investigation is worth examining as a model of how multiple independent lines of evidence can converge on the same conclusion, reinforcing each other in ways that make the total case stronger than any single element.

Consider the structure: the glasses provided the initial identification of a person of interest. Leopold’s explanation for the glasses — the birdwatching, the tripping, the Wilson’s phalarope — was plausible on its face, the kind of account that could not be immediately dismissed. Left alone, the glasses might not have been enough to bring charges, or might have been successfully challenged at trial.

But the glasses were not alone. The typewriter evidence arrived independently — through the study group notes, through the distinctive characteristics of the machine, through the eventual recovery of the machine from the lagoon. The typewriter evidence did not depend on the glasses evidence, and the glasses evidence did not depend on the typewriter evidence. Each pointed to Leopold through a separate chain.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.