By the end of the Revolution, virtually all the Haudenosaunee nations — regardless of which side they had chosen — had been uprooted from their traditional communities and were living in diminished circumstances. The Confederacy had been broken in ways that centuries of European contact and pressure had not managed to break it.

The Betrayal of the Peace

The Treaty of Paris in 1783 ended the Revolutionary War between the United States and Britain. It did not mention the Haudenosaunee. It did not mention the Oneida. It did not mention the specific promises that had been made to the Indigenous nations that had fought on both sides.

The Oneida had chosen the American side based on specific understandings of what that choice would mean for their future. The arguments made to them — by Samuel Kirkland, by American officials, by the rhetoric of liberty and freedom that animated the Revolutionary cause — had promised, in general terms if not always in specific legal commitments, that choosing the American cause would protect Oneida interests.

The peace did not fulfill these promises.

American settlement pressure on Oneida land began almost immediately after the war ended. The same westward expansion that the Mohawk had feared from the American cause, and that had helped motivate the Mohawk’s choice of the British side, was now being directed at the Oneida — the people who had fought for the Americans.

New York State and federal authorities negotiated a series of agreements with the Oneida in the years after the Revolution that reduced their territory dramatically. The Oneida Land Claims case — a legal dispute that persisted for more than a century — documented the systematic reduction of Oneida territory through agreements that were later found to have violated federal law.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.