The decision was wrong in one specific sense: it did not ultimately protect Oneida territorial integrity any better than the British alliance protected the Mohawk. Both the pro-American Oneida and the pro-British Mohawk lost their homelands as a result of the Revolution and its aftermath. But the decision was made in good faith, by people who were trying to navigate an impossible situation.
Tyonajanegen and Han Yerry were part of a community that had made this decision, and they acted on it with their bodies.
The Battle’s Geography: Oriskany Creek
The specific geography of the Battle of Oriskany is relevant to understanding what the fight was like and why it was so devastating to the American and Oneida forces that entered it.
Oriskany Creek flows northeast from the high ground of central New York to join the Mohawk River east of Rome. The creek’s course cut through terrain that was characterized by wooded slopes dropping to a narrow valley bottom. The road that Herkimer’s column was following crossed the creek at a point where the terrain naturally channeled movement — the road descended to the creek, crossed it, and ascended the other side, with the dip in the middle being both the most vulnerable point topographically and the point where the enemy could most effectively close the trap.
The specific ravine where the ambush was sprung has been described in multiple historical accounts. It was approximately six feet deep at some points, with the creek running through the bottom and the road crossing at a ford or simple bridge. The wooded slopes on either side provided cover for the ambushers and concealment for the approach that the Americans never detected.
