The Oneida and the Tuscarora chose the American side.

The reasons for the Oneida decision were specific and documented. Samuel Kirkland’s missionary relationships had built sustained ties between the Oneida leadership and the American colonial world. The Oneida had different experiences with the dynamics of colonial pressure than the Mohawk, who lived further east and whose relationship with the British administration had been shaped primarily by the Johnson family. Oneida leaders, including the principal sachem Shenendoah — also known as Skenandoa — made deliberate decisions that the American rebel cause offered a better future for Oneida sovereignty than the British alternative.

The result of these different choices was something the Confederacy had not experienced in its long history: Haudenosaunee fighting Haudenosaunee. The Battle of Oriskany, on August 6, 1777, was the specific moment when this possibility became reality. Mohawk warriors fought against Oneida warriors. The Great Law of Peace, which had forbidden war among the member nations for generations, could not survive what the Revolution had set in motion.

It was a civil war within the Confederacy, and its wounds would not heal within any period that the people who started it would live to see.

The Siege of Fort Schuyler

The Battle of Oriskany was not an isolated engagement. It was part of a specific strategic operation that the British had planned for the summer of 1777 — one of the three converging campaigns designed to separate New England from the rest of the colonies and end the Revolution.

Fort Schuyler — also known as Fort Stanwix, on the site of the modern city of Rome, New York — was the key to the western approach of this strategy. A British force under Lieutenant Colonel Barry St. Leger was moving east from Lake Ontario through the Mohawk Valley, intending to link up with General Burgoyne’s force coming south from Canada and General Howe’s force moving north from New York City. The plan, if all three columns reached their objectives, would have controlled the primary communications corridor of the northeastern colonies.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.