The process through which Bourdin obtained his travel documentation involved Spanish court certification, family identification provided by Carey Gibson, and application to American authorities. Each step in this process presented an opportunity for independent verification that did not, in the event, uncover the fraud.

The American consular office in Spain that processed the documentation was operating on the basis of the family identification and the Spanish court proceedings. The consular officer’s job in such a situation is to process a returning American citizen’s claim for emergency documentation, verify the basic credibility of the claim, and issue the document. Without fingerprint records or DNA comparison, the consular officer had no independent means of verifying that the person before them was actually Nicholas Barclay beyond the documentation provided and the family member’s attestation.

This is not a unique vulnerability of American consular processes. Any documentation system based primarily on attestation and paperwork can be exploited by someone who is able to generate plausible attestation and plausible paperwork. The consular officer who processed Bourdin’s documentation was not negligent in any way that the available record establishes. They were working within the systems and procedures that existed at the time.

—

## Life in the Barclay Home: What Observers Noticed

The five months that Bourdin spent in the Barclay home in San Antonio are, in some ways, the most remarkable period of the entire case. He was living in daily proximity to people who had known Nicholas Barclay personally, in a city where Nicholas had grown up, surrounded by institutional contexts, schools, neighborhood, family, where the real Nicholas had a documented history. The number of opportunities for the deception to collapse on any given day was substantial.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.