—
## Why Bourdin Chose Nicholas Barclay
The specific selection of Nicholas Barclay from among the many cases in the Center’s database has attracted attention in accounts of the case. Bourdin was in Spain in late 1997 and needed a credible American identity quickly. He had initiated contact with the Center under a false professional identity and had been provided with information about potential missing child cases.
The particular fit of Nicholas Barclay for Bourdin’s purposes in 1997 is worth examining. Nicholas had been missing for approximately three and a half years. That interval meant that the family would be encountering someone claiming to be Nicholas at an age meaningfully different from his age at disappearance. A three-and-a-half-year gap in a teenager’s development is substantial, and the expectation of significant change could potentially provide cover for discrepancies.
Nicholas had a relatively light paper trail of documentation beyond the missing persons report. He was not a child of prominent family, not a child whose disappearance had been extensively covered in national media, not a case with significant investigative resources devoted to it. He was a troubled teenager who had disappeared from a working-class neighborhood in a large Texas city, a case in a database rather than a cause celebre.
Bourdin was operating from Spain, which meant that the return would be a cross-border event, adding layers of institutional processing that could each be used to build credibility for the claim. A person who was processed through Spanish youth welfare, certified by a Spanish court, and cleared by an American consulate was arriving with multiple layers of institutional endorsement, each of which made subsequent independent questioning more difficult.
