Whether Bourdin thought through all of these factors explicitly in choosing Nicholas Barclay, or whether the selection was more opportunistic, is not established in the public record. The practical result is that the case he selected had features that made the impersonation more feasible than a randomly selected case might have been.

—

## The Testimony of Carey Gibson

Carey Gibson, Barclay’s sister, flew to Spain to retrieve the person claiming to be her brother and provided the sworn identification that enabled his travel documents. Her role in the case is in some ways the most puzzling, because she had a more recent and perhaps more direct knowledge of Nicholas than anyone else involved in the initial identification.

Carey was Nicholas’s older sister. She had lived with him in the same household. She knew what he looked like, how he moved, how he spoke. She was the person the family sent to Spain precisely because of this personal knowledge. And yet she signed the papers identifying the person before her as her brother.

Her own explanation, as recorded in documentary and news accounts, was that she believed the story. The eye color change from the eye drops, the French accent from forced language use, the physical changes from captivity. She saw someone who had the right approximate age, the right approximate height, the dyed blond hair, the replicated tattoos, and who was providing what seemed to her like explanations for the discrepancies.

Carey’s decision in Spain was made under extraordinary emotional pressure. She had flown across the Atlantic to bring home a brother she had not seen in three and a half years. The person in the room with her was claiming to be that brother, telling a story of terrible things that had happened to him. The alternative interpretation, that she was looking at a complete stranger who had somehow learned enough about her brother to construct a plausible claim, was not an interpretation that Spanish authorities or the Center’s database had raised. Everything official had endorsed the claim.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.