—
## The Reunion in Spain
Carey Gibson arrived in Linares and went to the youth shelter where the young man was being held. She was brought into a room with the person claiming to be Nicholas. By every account, the physical differences between this person and her brother were substantial. The person before her had brown eyes, not blue. He had a noticeable French accent. His build and manner were those of a young adult, not a teenager. Carey later acknowledged, in statements reported in the documentary record and in news accounts, that she had noticed some of these differences. She said she believed them. She signed papers attesting to his identity as Nicholas Barclay, an American citizen, and helped him obtain documentation for travel back to the United States.
How Carey came to identify this person as her brother has been a subject of much discussion. Her own explanation, repeated in multiple accounts, was that the differences could be explained by the story the young man told: he said he had been held by a child sex trafficking ring for years, that his captors had given him eye drops that changed his eye color, that he had been forced to speak French. Carey, in this telling, found these explanations plausible enough. Critics of this explanation have pointed out that it asks a great deal. Others, including researchers who have studied the case and the documentary that later examined it, have noted that people recovering long-lost relatives are strongly predisposed toward belief, especially when the alternative is accepting that the missing person is dead. The psychological literature on wishful identification is extensive, and there is nothing unprecedented about a family member accepting a highly improbable explanation rather than confronting a devastating reality.
