Since the Bourdin case, the use of DNA in missing persons cases and in the verification of claimed identity in missing persons reunifications has expanded substantially. The DNA Doe Project and similar organizations have used DNA analysis to identify previously unidentifiable remains. DNA databases maintained by various agencies have been used to establish the identity of people who cannot or will not identify themselves. The expansion of consumer DNA testing services has created additional databases that investigators have used, with varying legal frameworks, to identify individuals in cases where other methods have failed.
The specific scenario of a person fraudulently claiming to be a missing child would, in a modern context with DNA verification available from the outset, be much harder to sustain past initial screening. If a claiming-to-be-missing child could be routinely compared against a family DNA reference sample as part of the reunification process, Bourdin’s approach would have been stopped in Spain before Carey Gibson ever arrived.
—
## Frédéric Bourdin and the Question of Harm
The nature of the harm caused by Bourdin’s impersonation is worth examining carefully because it is not identical to the harm caused by most financial crimes, crimes of violence, or other categories of fraud. Bourdin did not steal money from the Barclay family. He did not physically harm anyone. He did not use his position in the home to commit crimes against the family members within it, as far as the documented record shows.
What he did was something that can be harder to categorize: he exploited a family’s grief over a missing child and built a five-month relationship with them based entirely on deception. He accepted Beverly Dollarhide’s care as a mother. He accepted Carey Gibson’s sisterly investment in his supposed return. He accepted whatever emotional resources the family put into welcoming back their missing child. And all of that acceptance was predicated on a lie.
