The specific harm of this kind of deception is harm to trust, harm to grief, harm to the ability to process the original loss of Nicholas. The Barclay family was already in a state of ongoing grief when Bourdin arrived. His impersonation did not give them Nicholas. It gave them five months of false hope followed by the destruction of that hope and the revelation that the person they had been caring for was a stranger. The re-opening of grief that followed this revelation, compounded by the investigation and questioning that came with Bourdin’s arrest, represents a harm that is real and significant even if it does not map onto the standard categories of criminal harm.

Federal courts recognized this, to some degree, in the sentence that exceeded guidelines. The nature of the crime was not just document fraud. It was the sustained exploitation of a family’s most vulnerable emotions over an extended period.

## The Specific Lie About Eye Color

Of all the physical discrepancies between Frédéric Bourdin and Nicholas Barclay, the eye color difference was the most immediately visible and the most difficult to explain away. Nicholas Barclay had blue eyes, documented in his missing persons file and in photographs taken during his lifetime. Bourdin had brown eyes. These are not subtly different shades of the same color. Blue and brown eyes represent different amounts of melanin in the iris, different biological characteristics that do not change under normal circumstances.

Bourdin’s explanation, the story about captors using eye drops to change his eye color, was medically implausible. No commonly available eye drops alter permanent iris color. Certain pharmaceutical preparations and specific medical conditions can affect iris pigmentation over time, but this is not something that can be administered through ordinary eye drops as a matter of control over a captive. The story asked the people hearing it to accept something with no basis in pharmacology or physiology.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.