That the story was accepted by Carey Gibson and by Beverly Dollarhide, at least initially, reflects the specific dynamics of motivated belief that this article has discussed at several points. When people desperately want something to be true, they process implausible explanations differently than they would under neutral conditions. The eye drop story was not evaluated as a medical claim. It was evaluated in the context of a family reunion that the people involved desperately wanted to believe was real.
Charlie Parker’s attention to the eye color was a function of his position as an outside observer without an emotional stake in the outcome. He was not invested in the person claiming to be Nicholas being Nicholas. He was looking at the footage with the eye of someone who had no prior relationship with the family and no emotional attachment to any particular conclusion. That outside perspective, emotionally detached and specifically focused on physical evidence, was what made the eye color discrepancy salient to him in a way it had not been to Carey or Beverly.
—
## The Investigation That Did Not Happen in 1994
One of the more sobering dimensions of the Barclay case is what it suggests about the investigation that did not happen in 1994 and the years immediately following Nicholas’s disappearance. If the question of what happened to Nicholas Barclay was eventually investigated with some seriousness in 1998, in the wake of Bourdin’s exposure, the question that naturally follows is why it was not investigated with that seriousness in 1994.
