The answer lies in the initial categorization of the case. A 13-year-old with a history of running away disappears the night before a court date. The natural interpretation is voluntary absence. Law enforcement opens a missing persons case but devotes resources appropriate to a probable runaway, not to a possible homicide or abduction. The case sits in the system. No body is found. No witnesses come forward. The investigation does not intensify because there is nothing specific to investigate.

This pattern is not unusual. Research on missing persons cases in the United States has documented that the initial categorization of a case, as a runaway versus as an abduction or possible homicide, dramatically affects the intensity and character of the response. Cases categorized as runaways receive substantially fewer investigative resources, and once a case is in the runaway category it can be difficult to shift that classification without compelling new evidence.

The compelling new evidence in the Barclay case did not come until 1997, when Bourdin created it by claiming to be Nicholas. That paradox is one of the stranger features of the case: the most intensive scrutiny of Nicholas Barclay’s original disappearance was triggered by a fraud that was itself premised on the fact that the original disappearance had not been fully investigated. Bourdin’s impersonation reopened questions that had been dormant, and the investigation that followed his exposure pushed harder on the circumstances of Nicholas’s original disappearance than the investigation in 1994 had.

—

## The Lasting Significance of an Unresolved Case

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.