—

## The Morphology Debate: What Skull Shape Can and Cannot Tell Us

The scientific debate over what Kennewick Man’s skull shape meant was not simply a dispute between scientists who wanted to study the bones and tribes who wanted to bury them. It was also a dispute within physical anthropology about the reliability and interpretation of morphological analysis.

The practice of assigning population affinity based on skull shape has a long and troubled history. In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, craniometry — the precise measurement of skull dimensions — was used to construct racial taxonomies that were then used to justify colonialism, segregation, and worse. The science was bad, and the applications were worse. Physical anthropology spent much of the second half of the twentieth century dismantling these frameworks.

Modern morphological analysis, as practiced by Owsley and his colleagues, operates on more sophisticated statistical grounds. Rather than assigning racial categories, practitioners compare the statistical distribution of a specimen’s measurements against reference populations and ask which population’s distribution the specimen falls closest to. The results are expressed in terms of probability and population affinity, not racial identity.

But critics raised a fundamental objection: human skull shape varies considerably within populations as well as between them. Any given individual may have features that fall outside the typical range for their population and within the range of another. A single skull, they argued, is simply not sufficient to draw reliable conclusions about population affinity. The statistical models require reference populations that are themselves reasonably well-characterized, and for ancient populations — including the ancestors of Kennewick Man — those reference populations do not exist.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.