Eske Willerslev, one of the DNA researchers who would later weigh in decisively on the question, made this point directly in discussing the 2015 study: morphological variation within populations is large enough that you cannot draw firm conclusions from one skull. What the skull resembles visually, or even statistically, may not reflect the individual’s actual population ancestry.

This was not a minor technical quibble. It went to the heart of the original controversy. If skull morphology is not reliable evidence of population affinity in an individual case, then the entire premise of Chatters’ initial framing — that the skull’s features were meaningful evidence that this individual was not ancestrally connected to present-day Native Americans — was much weaker than it had appeared.

—

## A Peripheral Legal Action: The Asatru Folk Assembly

The legal proceedings had an unusual sidebar. The Asatru Folk Assembly, a California-based organization following a reconstructed Norse religious tradition, filed its own claim to the Kennewick remains in late 1996. Their argument was that if the remains were of a “Caucasoid” individual, they might be culturally affiliated with their tradition, which revered ancient northern European ancestors.

The claim was largely dismissed by legal observers and was ultimately unsuccessful. Courts found no basis for the claim under any applicable legal framework. The Asatru Folk Assembly’s involvement was notable primarily as a demonstration of how the word “Caucasoid” in Chatters’ initial description had been understood — and misunderstood — by people seeking to use the case to support claims of ancient European presence in America.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.