Willerslev, the senior author, stated that his expectation was that the other four claimant tribes were also closely related to Kennewick Man, but that the data were not sufficient to say which tribe was closest. He stated explicitly that it was not possible, with the available data, to determine which present-day tribe had the closest relationship.
—
## What the Study Could Not Establish
The 2015 DNA study was important, but its authors were careful to delineate what it did and did not prove.
It did not establish a direct line of descent from Kennewick Man to any specific tribe. Population affinity — being genetically closer to Native Americans than to other groups — is not the same as direct ancestry. A finding that Kennewick Man belonged to the same broad genetic cluster as present-day Native Americans says that his population was ancestral to Native Americans in a general sense, or shared common ancestry with them, but does not establish that any living person is a descendant of this specific individual.
It also did not resolve the question of how the genetic signal should be mapped onto NAGPRA’s requirement of cultural affiliation. Douglas Owsley made this point after the study was published: NAGPRA, as written, requires a demonstrated link between the remains and a specific present-day tribe or culture, not merely a genetic relationship to Native Americans broadly. A finding that Kennewick Man was related to Native Americans in general, without being able to identify which tribe more specifically, did not necessarily satisfy the legal standard as the courts had interpreted it in 2002 and 2004.
