The study also rested on a very small sample of Native American genomes. As of the time of publication, relatively few Native American communities had participated in genome-wide sequencing studies. The comparison panel represented a fraction of the more than 500 federally recognized tribes. Any tribe that had not been sequenced could potentially be more closely related to Kennewick Man than the Colville. The study could identify the closest known relative, but could not rule out closer relatives among unstudied populations.

James Chatters, who had studied the bones from the beginning and who understood the morphological evidence better than almost anyone, was careful in his assessment. The study showed a shared Asian genetic heritage — a common ancestry going back to the original migrations that populated the Americas — but did not, in his view, establish a specific tribal connection. He called for wider sampling of Native American genomes before drawing specific conclusions.

—

## The Scientific Community’s Broader Response

For most scientists outside the immediate dispute, the 2015 DNA study was a significant development that substantially shifted the balance of evidence. The morphological hypothesis — that Kennewick Man represented a distinct, non-Native-American Paleoamerican population — had always rested on the shaky foundation of skull shape alone. The genomic data provided a fundamentally different and more reliable line of evidence.

Population genetics operates on principles that are not dependent on the visual assessment of individual specimens. When a genome is compared against a broad reference panel using statistical methods that account for drift, admixture, and population structure, the results reflect actual patterns of descent and shared ancestry. The finding that Kennewick Man’s genome clustered with Native Americans, and not with the Ainu or Polynesians, was not a close call. The genetic distances were clear.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.