For researchers in ancient DNA specifically, the study was part of a broader transformation in the field. The same period — roughly 2010 to 2020 — saw ancient DNA studies reshape understanding of European prehistory, of the peopling of the Pacific Islands, and of the complex migration history of the Americas. Studies of ancient remains from the Americas — including the roughly 12,600-year-old Anzick infant from Montana, whose genome also linked to modern Native Americans and was published in *Nature* in 2014 — built a picture of the first Americans as ancestral to present-day Native American populations, not replaced by them.
The specific Paleoamerican hypothesis — that early Americans were a distinct population swept aside by later arrivals — found little support in the genomic evidence.
—
## The Army Corps’ 2016 Determination
After the 2015 DNA publication, the Army Corps of Engineers undertook a review of the evidence in light of the new findings. In April 2016, the Corps issued a formal determination that the Kennewick Man remains were Native American within the meaning of NAGPRA.
This was a reversal of the Corps’ own earlier position — or rather, a reinstatement of the position it had taken in 1996, which the courts had then rejected. The difference in 2016 was that there was now genomic evidence supporting a Native American ancestral connection, in addition to the geographic and historical arguments the Corps had relied on in 1996.
The Corps’ 2016 determination reignited the legal dispute. Owsley and some of his colleagues argued that the determination did not resolve the NAGPRA affiliation question, which required a connection to a specific present-day tribe, not merely Native American ancestry generally. The legal standard, as the Ninth Circuit had interpreted it, was not satisfied by a finding of broad population affinity.
