—

## Population Affinity and Its Limits

The scientific resolution of the Kennewick Man case — the 2015 DNA study’s finding that he was genetically linked to Native Americans — rested on a concept that deserves careful examination: population affinity.

Population affinity, in the context of ancient DNA research, refers to the statistical relationship between an ancient individual’s genome and the genomes of modern populations. When researchers say that Kennewick Man was “more closely related to modern Native Americans than to any other population worldwide,” they are making a statement about where his genome falls in a statistical comparison — not a statement about identity, belonging, or specific descent.

The distinction matters. Genetic distance is a continuous variable, not a categorical one. A finding that Kennewick Man’s genome is genetically closer to the Colville than to the Ainu is a probabilistic statement about relative distances in a multidimensional genetic space. It does not mean that any living Colville person is a descendant of this specific individual. It does not mean that Kennewick Man would have understood himself as affiliated with any entity we would recognize as a tribe. The social, linguistic, religious, and political structures that define contemporary tribal identities did not exist 9,000 years ago.

This is not a reason to dismiss the DNA evidence, or to suggest that it has no bearing on questions of ancestry and belonging. It is a reason to be precise about what the evidence actually shows. The 2015 study showed that Kennewick Man’s population was ancestral to — or shared common ancestry with — present-day Native American populations. That is a meaningful finding. It is a different finding from establishing that he was a member of the Colville tribe, or that any specific person living today has this individual in their direct family tree.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.