The tribal position — that oral history, cultural continuity, and long residence on the land established a connection to the Ancient One that did not require genetic proof — was making a different kind of claim. Tribal identity is not, and has never been, primarily a matter of DNA. It is a matter of community, culture, language, ceremony, and belonging. The question of whether a 9,000-year-old individual belongs to a present-day tribe cannot be resolved by genomics alone, whatever the genomic evidence shows.

—

## The Role of Oral History and Tradition

The five claimant tribes had maintained from the beginning of the dispute that their oral histories established their ancestral connection to the Ancient One. Armand Minthorn and other tribal leaders spoke consistently about traditions going back 10,000 years, about ceremonies and practices that had been transmitted across the generations, about a relationship with the land along the Columbia River that predated any written record.

The legal and scientific proceedings largely sidelined this evidence. NAGPRA allowed oral tradition as one type of evidence for cultural affiliation, but the courts, in their 2002 and 2004 rulings, found that oral tradition alone — without supporting biological, archaeological, or historical evidence specific to this individual — was not sufficient to establish the kind of connection the statute required.

This created a situation that many scholars of NAGPRA found troubling. The law was designed to protect the rights of Native American tribes to their ancestral remains. But in its application, it required tribes to prove those rights using evidentiary frameworks that had been developed by and for the dominant scientific and legal culture — frameworks that treated oral history as inherently less reliable than physical or genetic evidence.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.