The irony was profound: tribes were being asked to prove, using the methodologies of the people who had disrupted their communities, that the ancient dead were their own.

—

## James Chatters’ Evolving Position

James Chatters’ role in the Kennewick Man case was complex, and his public statements evolved over the two decades of the dispute.

His initial description of the skull as “Caucasoid” at the 1996 press conference set the terms of the controversy in ways that he later said he had not intended. He used the term in what he described as a technical morphological sense, without meaning to imply European ancestry. When his words were reported as suggesting that Kennewick Man might have been a “Caucasian” or even a European, he disputed that interpretation.

Over the years that followed, Chatters maintained his view that the morphological evidence was real and important — that the skull’s features genuinely resembled those of Pacific Rim populations, and that this was meaningful information about the population history of early North America. He was not persuaded that the morphological evidence should simply be set aside because it was inconvenient for a particular political or legal outcome.

After the 2015 DNA study, Chatters accepted that the genomic evidence was significant but raised the sampling objection: with only two Colville individuals in the comparison panel, and with most Native American tribes unsequenced, the study’s conclusion that Kennewick Man was most closely related to the Colville was based on limited data. He was not prepared to say the question was settled.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.