This was a defensible scientific position, though some of his colleagues in ancient DNA research found it overly conservative. The statistical methods used in the 2015 study were robust, they argued, and the finding of Native American affinity was not dependent on the Colville sample specifically — it held when tested against Native Americans broadly.

—

## Eske Willerslev and the Collaboration

One aspect of the 2015 DNA study that distinguished it from the preceding decades of conflict was the way the research team approached the tribes.

Eske Willerslev, the senior author, had a track record of working collaboratively with indigenous communities. His research group had earlier sequenced the genome of a 4,000-year-old individual from Greenland, which required cooperation with the Greenlandic Inuit community. He had also worked on the Anzick infant study, in which the Crow and other Northern Plains tribes were involved as partners in the research.

For the Kennewick study, the team sought the participation of the five claimant tribes. Four of the five — the Umatilla, the Yakama, the Nez Perce, and the Wanapum — declined to contribute DNA samples or to participate in the study. Their position was consistent with their longstanding objection to scientific examination of the remains: they did not need a DNA study to know the Ancient One was their ancestor, and participating in one implied an acceptance of the burden-of-proof framework that the legal proceedings had imposed on them.

The Colville, however, agreed to participate. Two Colville members provided DNA samples. Their contribution made possible the comparison that produced the specific finding about proximity to the Colville — the finding that was most directly relevant to the tribal claims.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.