C. Vance Haynes Jr. was at the University of Arizona, a specialist in geoarchaeology and Pleistocene environments who had contributed substantially to understanding the conditions under which early humans migrated into the Americas.

Dennis J. Stanford was at the Smithsonian. He was one of the most prominent proponents of the Solutrean hypothesis — the theory that early Americans may have included migrants from Ice Age Europe who crossed the Atlantic ice shelf. This hypothesis was not widely accepted in the field, but it reflected his interest in questioning the assumption that all early Americans descended from a single Asian migration.

Douglas Owsley, also at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History, was perhaps the most publicly prominent of the plaintiffs in the years that followed. As the head of the Division of Physical Anthropology at the National Museum of Natural History, he had examined thousands of skeletal remains and was known as one of the most experienced forensic and physical anthropologists in the country.

D. Gentry Steele of Texas A&M University rounded out the group.

Their collective interest was in preserving access to what they regarded as a rare and scientifically invaluable specimen. Complete or near-complete human skeletons from the early postglacial period in North America were extraordinarily uncommon. The chance to study an individual this old in this much detail — to examine his diet through isotopic analysis, his health through his bones, his life through the traces of injury and healing — was, they argued, irreplaceable. If the remains were reburied without study, that scientific opportunity would be gone permanently.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.