If he was deliberately buried, then the question of whose ancestor he is takes on a different dimension. He was not just a person who happened to die near the river. He was a person whose death was marked by people who cared for him. Those people are the ones whose cultural practices, whose ceremonies, whose understanding of the proper treatment of the dead are the most directly relevant to how he should be treated today.
Whether the ceremonies of the five claimant tribes are the same as or related to the ceremonies that buried Kennewick Man 9,000 years ago is a question that cannot be definitively answered. But the tribal position — that their traditions of caring for the dead are continuous with those of their ancestors, and that those ancestors include the Ancient One — is not simply an assertion of legal interest. It is a claim about cultural continuity and moral responsibility that the act of burial, 9,000 years ago, makes relevant.
—
## The Debate Over Cultural Continuity
One of the deeper intellectual questions raised by the Kennewick case concerns cultural continuity: in what sense can present-day tribal cultures be understood as continuous with the cultures of people who lived 9,000 years ago?
The question is not rhetorical. Nine thousand years is a very long time. Languages change. Social structures evolve. Subsistence practices shift with the environment. The specific ceremonies and beliefs of any given period in prehistory cannot be known from the archaeological record alone, and cannot simply be assumed to match those of modern communities without evidence.
