The connection between this ancient material culture and the living tribes of the plateau is not simple to establish archaeologically. Archaeologists work with material culture — with the objects people made and left behind — and the correspondence between specific types of objects and specific tribal identities is never straightforward. Cultural practices persist, change, and merge across generations in ways that the archaeological record captures only imperfectly.
But the broader picture — of people living on the Columbia Plateau, fishing its rivers, hunting its game, moving across its landscape for at least 9,000 years before the arrival of Euro-Americans — is consistent with the tribal oral histories that describe long presence in the region. The archaeological record and the oral traditions are not in conflict. They are describing the same landscape, inhabited over very long periods of time.
—
## The 2016 Army Corps Determination: Details
The Army Corps of Engineers’ April 2016 determination that the Kennewick remains were Native American within the meaning of NAGPRA was based on two lines of evidence: the 2015 DNA study and an independent confirmation of that study’s findings by a team at the University of Chicago.
The Chicago team’s confirmation — conducted at the Corps’ request to verify the Nature paper’s conclusions — found the same result: the genome was genetically closer to Native Americans, including the Colville, than to any other population worldwide. This independent replication addressed one potential objection: that the original study might have been subject to biases or methodological choices that could have affected the result. With an independent team reaching the same conclusion, the genomic finding was more robust.
