The Corps’ determination was not, however, simply a matter of accepting the DNA evidence at face value. It also involved a legal judgment: that the genomic evidence was sufficient, in combination with the geographic and contextual evidence already in the record, to establish the kind of affiliation that NAGPRA required. This was the judgment that Owsley and his colleagues disputed — not the DNA findings themselves, but their legal sufficiency.

Whether the Corps was right on this legal point is debatable. The courts’ earlier rulings had imposed a standard of proof that arguably could not be met by genomic evidence alone, because the law contemplated a specific tribal affiliation, not just a general genetic connection to Native Americans. Owsley’s position — that this was ultimately a question for the courts, not for the Army Corps — had genuine legal logic behind it.

Congress’ decision to bypass that debate through legislation was a choice to resolve a political impasse by political means. It was not, technically, a resolution of the underlying legal question about NAGPRA’s scope. The question of how the law applies to very ancient remains without specific tribal connections remains open in a general sense, even though the Ancient One’s specific case is closed.

—

## The Voices of the Five Tribes

Throughout the two decades of the Kennewick case, the five claimant tribes — the Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation, the Yakama Nation, the Nez Perce Tribe, the Colville Confederated Tribes, and the Wanapum Band — maintained a consistent position: the Ancient One was their ancestor, and he deserved to be returned to the earth.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.