Armand Minthorn was perhaps the most visible spokesperson for the tribal position from the beginning. His statements were clear and consistent. In 1996, shortly after the discovery: “Our oral histories go back 10,000 years. We know this individual is a descendant of ours.” After the press conference that described the skull as Caucasoid: the tribes viewed the excavation and examination as a desecration. After the 2004 court ruling that allowed scientific study: the tribes continued to object and to pursue every available legal avenue to secure the return of the remains.
Marla Big Boy, the Colville attorney general, was explicitly critical of the scientific community’s handling of the case. She described what she saw as “scientific and professional arrogance” in the assumption that the right to study the remains was paramount. She linked the approach to a longer history of mistreatment of Native peoples by governmental and scientific institutions.
JoDe Goudy, chairman of the Yakama Nation Tribal Council, was present at the 2017 reburial. His statement — “The Ancient One may now finally find peace” — expressed the relief and vindication that the tribes felt after two decades of effort.
The tribal voices in the Kennewick case were clear, consistent, and grounded in a long history of experience with governmental and scientific institutions that had not always acted in good faith toward Native American communities. The patience required to maintain that position through twenty years of litigation, while watching the remains of an ancestor being examined and debated, was itself a form of witness.
