The Corps took the position that the age of the remains and their geographic location on historically Umatilla land was sufficient to establish a presumption of affiliation. Critics of that position argued that simply being old and in a place where Native Americans have lived is not the same as establishing affiliation with any specific present-day tribe.

This legal ambiguity was not academic. It determined whether the remains could be studied or whether they had to be immediately reburied.

—

## The Scientists’ Lawsuit

On October 16, 1996, eight scientists filed a lawsuit in federal court in Portland, Oregon. The case was *Bonnichsen v. United States*. The plaintiffs were:

Robson Bonnichsen, then at Oregon State University and director of the Center for the Study of the First Americans. C. Loring Brace, a physical anthropologist at the University of Michigan. George W. Gill of the University of Wyoming. C. Vance Haynes Jr. of the University of Arizona. Richard L. Jantz of the University of Tennessee. Douglas Owsley of the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of Natural History. Dennis J. Stanford of the Smithsonian. D. Gentry Steele of Texas A&M University.

Their argument was straightforward in its essential logic: the Army Corps had acted too quickly. The remains had not been shown, under the legal standard that NAGPRA required, to be “Native American” within the meaning of the statute. NAGPRA defined “Native American” as “of, or relating to, a tribe, people, or culture that is indigenous to the United States.” The scientists argued that remains from more than 9,000 years ago, before any present tribal culture as now defined had come into existence, did not automatically qualify under this definition. If NAGPRA did not apply, the remains were subject to the Archaeological Resources Protection Act, which governed archaeological materials on federal lands — and which allowed scientific study.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.