The isotopic analysis — particularly the strontium isotopes used to infer geographic origins and the carbon and nitrogen isotopes used to reconstruct diet — showed the patterns described earlier: a diet heavily dependent on marine resources, suggesting substantial time near the Pacific coast, and a geographic signature inconsistent with the Kennewick area itself.
The morphological analysis produced the conclusions that attracted the most controversy: skull features closest to Pacific Rim populations, specifically the Ainu and Polynesians, rather than to modern Native Americans. This finding was presented in the 2014 volume as evidence that Kennewick Man represented a population distinct from the ancestors of most present-day Native Americans.
One year later, the 2015 DNA study produced evidence that directly contradicted this interpretation. The genomic data placed Kennewick Man within the Native American genetic cluster, not outside it. The morphological findings were real in the sense that the measurements were accurate — but their interpretation, the scientists now had to acknowledge, had been substantially wrong.
This trajectory — a decade of morphological study leading to a conclusion that was then refuted by genomic evidence — was instructive for the field. It did not mean that morphological analysis is useless or that the work of the plaintiff scientists was wasted. The osteological, isotopic, and other analyses contributed genuinely to understanding how Kennewick Man had lived. The error was in the interpretation of morphological features as evidence of population affinity in an individual case. That interpretation had always been contested within physical anthropology. The genomic evidence resolved the contest.
