In July 1999, an independent scientific panel conducted a preliminary, non-destructive study at the Burke. The panel found features in the skeleton common to Native Americans, Europeans, and Asians, with what they described as the strongest resemblance to Polynesian populations. This finding complicated the picture — it was neither the straightforward “this is a Native American” result that the tribes sought nor the definitive “this is not Native American” result that might have conclusively resolved the NAGPRA question.

—

## The Interior Department Weighs In

In September 2000, Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt issued a determination that the Kennewick remains could be classified as Native American under NAGPRA and should be repatriated to the five claimant tribes. His determination rested on the geographic connection — the remains had been found on traditional tribal lands — and on a broad reading of what NAGPRA’s affiliation requirement demanded. He concluded that the tribes’ long historical presence in the region, combined with the remains’ location, was sufficient to establish the kind of connection the law required.

The plaintiff scientists, through their legal team, challenged Babbitt’s determination. They argued that his reading of NAGPRA stretched the statute beyond what Congress had intended, and that a geographic connection alone — without specific evidence of cultural, biological, or historical links between this individual and any present-day tribe — was not the kind of affiliation the law had in mind.

The litigation continued.

—

## The 2002 Ruling: Scientists Win the Right to Study

On August 30, 2002, Magistrate Judge Jelderks issued a ruling that was a substantial victory for the plaintiff scientists. He found that the evidence was insufficient to establish that the remains were “Native American” under NAGPRA’s definition. The ruling turned on the legal question of what the statute required: Jelderks concluded that the law demanded a demonstrated relationship between the ancient remains and a present-day tribe, not merely geographic proximity or presumed antiquity.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.