He also had to process the information about Jill.

 

 

## The Missing Twin

 

Jill Rosenthal’s absence is the unresolved heart of this case.

 

She and Jack had disappeared at approximately the same time — before their second birthdays, in the mid-1960s, from a household that relatives described as chaotic and dangerous. Jack had been found in Newark. Jill had not been found anywhere.

 

The working theory, among investigators and among the man who had been raised as Paul Fronczak, was that something had happened to Jill that was different from what happened to Jack. Jack had been abandoned in a public place where he was found relatively quickly and placed in foster care; his eventual physical survival was enabled by the intervention of strangers. Jill had not been abandoned in any way that was recorded, found by any authority, or placed in any system that left a trace.

 

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which became involved in the case as it attracted public attention, created age-progressed composite images of what Jill might look like as an adult. These images were based on photographs and descriptions of her biological relatives — including, eventually, the man now known to be her twin brother — and they represented the standard investigative tool for cases of children who have been missing since early childhood.

 

No photographs of Jill Rosenthal as a child are known to exist. The Rosenthals had removed the twins’ photographs from the family album. The specific decision to remove those photographs — to erase the visual record of the children’s existence — is one of the details of the case that sits with particular weight. It was a deliberate act. It required recognizing that photographs existed and choosing to eliminate them. It suggests that whatever happened to Jill, the Rosenthals had reason to ensure that her image did not circulate.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.