The investigative tools available in 1964 were limited by the standards of subsequent decades. There was no CCTV footage — surveillance camera systems were not yet installed in hospitals. There was no DNA analysis. There were no digital records. The investigation relied on witness accounts, physical evidence, and leads generated by the mass distribution of photographs and descriptions. None of these produced an identification.
As the decades passed, the kidnapper aged. By 2019, when Kevin Baty was identified as the missing baby, the woman would have been at minimum in her 70s, more likely in her 80s or 90s, or dead. The specific investigative tools that had identified Baty through genetic genealogy — the analysis of DNA databases, the construction of family trees from genetic matches — were applicable to identifying Baty because Baty was alive and had biological relatives in the databases. They were not directly applicable to identifying a kidnapper whose identity was entirely unknown and who had left no traceable genetic evidence.
The 1964 kidnapping remains open. The question of who took Paul Fronczak from his mother’s arms in April 1964, and why, and what motivated the specific choice of that specific hospital and that specific baby, has no answer in the public record.
## Dora’s Phone Calls
The final months of Kevin Baty’s life — the period between his identification as the missing Paul Fronczak in December 2019 and his death in April 2020 — are documented only briefly in the available public record, but what that record contains is significant.
Dora Fronczak, in her 80s and having spent 55 years believing that the child she had brought home from New Jersey was her biological son, learned in December 2019 that her biological son had been found — not in New Jersey, not in the case that had dominated her family’s history, but in Michigan, through a genetic genealogy investigation that used tools that had not existed when her son was taken.
