She and Kevin Baty spoke by phone. The specific content of those conversations has not been made public in detail, but their existence is confirmed. They were planning to meet. They did not meet before Baty’s cancer progressed and he died.
What those phone calls represented — for a woman who had waited more than five decades for the son who was taken from her arms in a hospital ward, and for a man who had presumably grown up without knowing the full story of his origins — cannot be fully rendered by any external description. They were private conversations between a mother and the son she had not seen since he was 36 hours old.
Baty died on April 26, 2020. He was 56 years old. His birthday was the same as the day of his birth, which was also the day before his abduction: April 26, 1964. He died on the anniversary of the day he was born.
## The Case As an Identity Problem
The Paul Fronczak case — using that name in its conventional, case-identifier sense, referring to the full set of events including the 1964 abduction, the 1965 Newark abandonment, the 2012 DNA result, the 2015 Rosenthal identification, and the 2019 Baty identification — is ultimately an identity problem in several senses of that term.
It is an identity problem in the most literal sense: the problem of establishing, with certainty, who specific individuals are. The 1965 identification of Scott McKinley as Paul Fronczak was an attempt to solve this problem with the tools available at the time — physical resemblance, age consistency, and the absence of a definitive disqualifying factor — and it was wrong. The 2012 DNA test corrected the error, but left new problems in its place. The 2015 genetic genealogy investigation solved the question of who the man raised as Paul actually was, but created the unresolved question of Jill. The 2019 investigation solved the question of what had happened to the original missing baby, but could not resolve the question of who had taken him or bring Dora and her son to the meeting they had planned.
