That guidance was wrong. The assessment was wrong. The identification was wrong.

 

The wrongness of the FBI’s identification was not a matter of bad faith or incompetence, as best the available record indicates. It was a matter of the limits of the tools available in 1965. The FBI did not have DNA testing. It did not have preserved footprints. It had physical characteristics, age consistency, and an inability to find any other child that fit the available criteria. Within those constraints, the conditional identification — cannot rule out — was the most accurate statement that the available evidence supported.

 

But the institutional weight of the FBI’s statement — the authority with which a federal investigation tells a grieving family that this is your best and only lead — created conditions in which the Fronczaks would have had to disbelieve the FBI in order to refuse the identification. That is not a reasonable expectation of behavior. They followed the guidance of the investigation that was supposed to find their son, and the guidance was wrong.

 

The resolution of the case — the 2012 DNA test, the 2015 genealogy identification, the 2019 FBI identification of Kevin Baty — involved the FBI’s own acknowledgment that its 1965 conditional identification had been incorrect, and its subsequent engagement with the genetic genealogy investigation that eventually identified the real missing baby. The institution that had made the error was also, eventually, part of the process that corrected it.

 

## The Atlantic City Origins

 

Atlantic City, New Jersey, in 1963 and 1964, was a city in transition. The resort economy that had made it famous — the boardwalk, the hotels, the entertainment — was beginning the long decline that would continue until the casino era that began in the late 1970s. The city’s permanent population included working-class families of various ethnicities, including the Rosenthals, who were among the thousands of people living in the neighborhoods away from the tourist zones.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.