Finding Jill, or finding out what happened to her, remains the unresolved thread of a case that has otherwise found its major answers — imperfectly, incompletely, with the losses that the decades imposed, but answered.

 

The databases continue to grow.

 

## A Mirror Image Problem

 

The Paul Fronczak case has been described in various ways by those who have reported on it: a kidnapping case, a mistaken identity case, a true crime story, a survival narrative. All of these framings capture something true about the case. None of them fully captures the specific quality that makes it unusual.

 

The case is, at its deepest level, a mirror image problem. There are two Pauls: the Paul Fronczak who was raised in Chicago — the man identified as Jack Rosenthal — and the Paul Fronczak who was taken from the hospital — the man identified as Kevin Baty. Each of them was living, for more than fifty years, in a reality that was partially constituted by the other’s absence. The man raised as Paul could not have his true identity as long as the question of the original Paul remained officially resolved by his presence. The original Paul could not be found as long as the case was considered closed by the existence of the man raised as Paul.

 

The DNA test of 2012 is the moment when the mirror cracked. It revealed not one mistaken identity but two simultaneous mistaken identities: the man raised as Paul was not Paul, and therefore Paul was still missing, and therefore the resolution of 1965 had been an error.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.