This chapter of the case is among the least documented in the publicly available record. The specific households in which he was placed, the specific foster parents who cared for him, the specific experiences he had during this period — these are not documented in the available accounts. What is known is that he was placed in foster care by New Jersey authorities, given the name Scott McKinley, and that the FBI’s investigation of his possible identity eventually led to the conditional identification that brought the Fronczaks to New Jersey.

 

The foster care system in New Jersey in 1965-1967 was operating under the institutional frameworks of its era. Foster care in the mid-1960s was a system under significant strain, inadequately resourced for the volume of children it served, governed by regulations that have since been substantially revised in the direction of greater oversight and accountability. The specific quality of the care he received during this period is unknown.

 

What is documented, in a limited way, is that the Fronczaks’ first exposure to him was described in terms of an identification process — they came to see the child and assess whether he might be their son. The identification, as described in contemporaneous accounts, was emotional and not strictly forensic: they saw a toddler who might have been the right age, who had certain physical characteristics that did not conflict with who Paul might have become, and who was the FBI’s last remaining unexcluded possibility.

 

The transition from Scott McKinley to Paul Fronczak — from a child in New Jersey foster care with a temporary institutional name to a child with a family and a name — was the beginning of the life he would live for the next half-century.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.